Rural School Consolidation: History, Research Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations

Joe Bard, Clark Gardener, Regi Wieland

Abstract


The consolidation of rural schools in the United States has been a controversial topic for policy-makers, school administrators, and rural communities since the 1800s. At issue in the consolidation movement have been concerns of efficiency, economics, student achievement, school size, and community identity. Throughout the history of schooling in America, school consolidation has been a way to solve rural issues in the eyes of policy makers and many education officials. Today, faced with declining enrollments and financial cutbacks, many rural schools and communities continue to deal with challenges associated with possible school reorganizations and consolidations. This paper, developed by the NREA Consolidation Task Force, provides a review of the literature on rural school consolidation, defines consolidation, addresses current research and issues related to consolidation with respect to school size, economies of scale, and student achievement, and concludes with proposed recommendations for the NREA Executive Board.

References


Altman, I. & Low, S. (Eds.), (1992). Place attachment. New York: Plenum Press.

Anderson, D. (1993). A rural perspective on school consolidation in Ontario, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation. University of Toronto, Toronto.

Augenblick, J., Myers, J. & Silverstein, J. (2001,January 10). A comprehensive study on the organization of Kansas school districts. Prepared for the Kansas State Board of Education in response to RFP Number 00241. Augenblick and Myers, Inc.

Axelrod, M. (February 1956). Urban structure and social participation. American Sociological Review, 21, 13-18.

Beggs, J., Hurlbert, J., & Haines, V. (1996). Community attachment in a rural setting: A refinement and empirical test of the systemic model. Rural Sociology 61 (3), 407-426.

Biere, A. (1995). Community change. In Lasley, et. al’s. Beyond the amber waves of grain. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Bushnell, M. (Fall, 1999). Imagining rural life: Schooling as a sense of place. Journal of Research in Rural Education, 15 (2), 80-89.

Camus (1955). The myth of sisyphus. New York: Vintage Books.

Chance, E., & Cummins, C. (Winter, 1998). School/community survival: Successful strategies used in rural school district consolidations. Rural Educator, 20 (2) 1-7.

Conant, J. (1959). The American high school today: A first report to interested citizens. New York: McGraw Hill.

Cotton, K. (1999) School size, school climate, and student performance. School Improvement Research Series. Northwest Regional Educational Laboratory, Portland, OR. Retrieved from Northwest Regional Education Laboratory Web site: http://www.nwrel.org/scpd/sirs/10/c020.html

Cox, D. (January 2002). Big trouble: Solving education problems means rethinking super-size districts and schools. Retrieved Jan. 4, 2005 from the Sutherland Institute. Web site:

http://sutherlandinstitute.org/Publications/FocusonUtah/SmallerDistricts/SmallerDistricts.htm

Crumbaker, D. (1980). Reorganization of school districts: Late 1950s to present time. Paper presented at Kansas State University Rural and Small School Conference, Manhattan, KS.

Cubberly, Elwood P. (1914). State and county educational reorganization. New York: Macmillan.

DeYoung, Alan (1989). Economics and American education: A historical and critical overview of the impact of economic theories on schooling in the United States. New York: Longman Press.

DeYoung, Alan (1995). The life and death of a rural American high school: Farewell Little Kanawha. New York: Garland.

DeYoung, Alan J., & Howley, Craig B. (1992). The political economy of rural school consolidation. (Report No. RC-018-660). (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 347-018)

DeYoung, Alan J., & Kannapel, Patricia J. (Fall, 1999). The rural school problem in 1999: A review and critique of the literature. Journal of Research in Rural Education, 15 (2), 67-69.

Digest of education statistics. 1997. Table 90. Public school districts & enrollment by size of district. 1988-89 to 1995-96.

Eyre, Eric & Finn, Scott. (2002) Closing costs: School consolidation in West Virginia. Charleston Gazette. Charleston, WV. Series on the costs of school consolidation running August 25 and 30, Sept. 8, 12, 24, 29, and Oct. 3 and 6.

Finney, Ross, and Schafer, Alfred J. (1920). The administration of village and consolidated schools. New York: Macmillan.

Fitchen, Janet M. (1991). Endangered spaces, enduring places, change, identity and survival in rural America. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Fitzwater, C.O. (1953). Educational change in reorganized school districts. Washington D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

Flora, Cornelia Butler, Flora, Jan L., Spear, Jacqueline D., and Swanson, Louis E. (19??). Rural Communities: Legacy & Change. Boulder, San Francisco, Oxford: Westview Press.

Fox, W.F. (1981). Reviewing economies of size in education. Journal of Education Finance, 6 (3), 273-296.

Funk P. E. & Bailey J. (1999). Small schools, big results: Nebraska high school completion and postsecondary enrollment rates by size of school district. Nebraska Alliance for Rural Education.

Gerson, K., Stueve, C.A., & Fischer, C. (1977). Attachment to place. In C. Fischer, R. Jackson, C. Stueve, K. Gerson, & L. Jones. Networks and places 139-161. New York: The Free Press.

Glascock, Catherine H. (1998). Rural districts in crisis: When a community is divided. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. ED 419 633

Goudy, W.J. (1982). Further considerations of indicators of community attachment. Social Indicators Research, 11, 181-192.

Hirsch, W.Z. (1960). Determinants of Public Education Expenditure. National Tax Journal, 13(1), pp.29-40.

Hobbs, D. (1991). Rural education. In Flora, C.B. and Christenson, J.A. (Eds.) Rural policies for the 1990’s. Boulder: Westview Press.

Howley, C. (1991). The rural education dilemma as part of the rural dilemma: Rural education and economics. In DeYoung, A.J. (Eds.) Rural education: Issues and practice. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc.

Howley, Craig B., & Eckman, John M., (Eds.) (1997). Sustainable small schools: A handbook for rural communities, ERIC clearinghouse on rural education and small schools. Charleston, West Virginia.

Howley, Craig (2000). School district size and school performance. Rural Education Issue Digest. Retrieved January 2005 from AEL Web site: www.ael.org/rel/rural/pdf/digest3.pdf

Howley, Craig & Bickel, Robert. (2001). Smaller districts: Closing the gap for poor kids. Retrieved March 2005 http://oak.cats.ohiou.edu/~howleyc/asbj2.htm

Henderson, Ronald D., & Gomez, J.J. (1975). The consolidation of rural schools: Reasons, results, and implications. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Rural Sociological Society (August).

Hunter, A. (1974). Symbolic Communities. University of Chicago Press.

Ilvento, T.W. (1990). In Luloff, A., & Swanson, L. (Eds.) Education and community. Boulder: Westview Press.

Imerman, Mark & Otto, Dan. (2003, January). A preliminary investigation of school district expenditures with respect to school district size in Iowa. Retrieved from the Department of Economics Iowa State University Web site: www.econ.iastate.edu/research/webpapers/paper-10183.pdf

Jewell, R.W. (February 1989). School and School District Size Relationships. Education and Urban Society. 140-153.

Kammerzell, Mary Sundby (1994). Perceptions of community residents toward school consolidation: A qualitative case study. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Nebraska, Lincoln.

Kasarda, J., & Janowitz, M. (June 1974). Community attachment in mass society. American Sociological Review, 39, 328-339.

Kay, S., Hargood, N., and Russell, R.K. (1982). The effect of consolidation on fidelity to traditional value systems. Frankfort: Kentucky State University Community Research Service.

Keith, G. (1970) Unification in Kansas, A progress report, 1858-1969. Unpublished Kansas State Department of Education report, Topeka, KS.

Keith, George D. (1970). Reorganization of school districts in Kansas. Kansas State Department of Education, Topeka, KS.

Kennedy, Robert L. et al. (Jan. 1989). Expenditures, MAT6 scores and dropout rates: A correlational study of Arkansas School Districts. ERIC Accession No. ED303910.

Krietlow, Burton W. (1966). Long-term study of educational effectiveness of newly formed centralized school districts in rural areas. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Wisconsin.

Lasley, Paul, Leistritz, Larry, F., Lobao, Linda M., & Meyer, Katherine, (1995). Beyond the amber waves of grain. Westview Press: Boulder, CO.

Lawrence, Barbara K, Bingler, Steven, Diamond, Barabara M., Hill, Bobbie, Hoffman, Jerry L. Howley, Craig B., Mitchell, Stacy; Rudolph, David, & Washor, Elliot. (2002, September). Dollars & sense: The cost effectiveness of small schools. [Electronic version]. Retrieved Jan. 2005 from The Rural School and Community Trust Web site: http://www.ruraledu.org/docs/dollars.htm

Lewis, Jim (2004). The long and winding road: Consolidation—the separation of school and community. Retrieved Feb. 9, 2005 from the Challenge West Virginia Web site: http://www.challengewv.org

Lu, Y. & Tweeten, L. (1973). The impact of busing on student achievement. Growth and Change, 4(4), 44-46.

Luloff, A., & Swanson, L. (Eds.) (1990). Education and community. Boulder: Westview Press.

Lyson, T.A. (2002). What Does a School Mean to a Community? Assessing the Social and Economic Benefits of Schools to Rural Villages in New York. Department of Rural Sociology, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York.

Manzo, Kathleen Kennedy (1999). North Dakota schools struggle with enrollment declines. Education week. 19 (10)

Migyanko, Madelyn Ramona (1992). A case study of the impact of organizational changes on the educational climate of a school district. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Cincinnati, Ohio.

Nachtigal, Paul, (Ed.) (1982). In search of a better way. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Nelson, (1985). School consolidation. Washington D.C. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 282 346)

Orr, David W. (1992). Ecological literacy: Education and the transition to a postmodern world. New York: State University of New York Press.

Peshkin, Alan. (1982) The imperfect union: School consolidation and community conflict. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Peshkin, Alan (1978). Growing up american. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Phelps, M.S. and Prock, G.A. (1991). Equality of educational opportunity. In DeYoung, A.J. (Ed), Rural education: Issues and practice. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc.

Picard, Cecil J. (2003). Small school districts and economies of scale. Presented to the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education at the May 2003 Strategic Planning Study Group Committee. Louisiana Department of Education.

Pittman, R.B., & Haughwout, P. (1987). Influence of high school size on dropout rate. Educational and policy analysis. Winter 1987, 337-343.

Post, David, & Stambach, Amy (Fall, 1999). District consolidation and rural school closure: E pluribus unum? Journal of Research in Rural Education, 15(2), 106-117.

Proshansky, H.M., Fabian, A.K., & Kaminoff, R. (1983). Place identity: Physical world socialization of the self. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 3, 57-83.

Purdy, D.H. (1997). An economical, thorough, and efficient school system. The West Virginia school building authority. Economy of scale numbers. Journal of Research in Rural Education, 13 (3), 170-182.

Ravitch, Diane, (1983). The troubled crusade, New York: Basic Books.

Raywid, Mary Ann. ((January 1999). Current literature on small schools. ERIC Digest EDO-RC-98-8. Retrieved from AEL Web site: http://ael.org

Reeves, Cynthia (January, 2004). A decade of consolidation: Where are the $avings? A Challenge West Virginia document. Retrieved from Challenge West Virginia Web site:

http://www.challengewv.org/resources.html

Relph, E. (1976). Place and placelessness. London: Pion Riley, Robert B. (1992) Attachment to the ordinary landscape. In Altman, I., & Low, S.M., (Eds.) Place Attachment. New York: Plenum Press.

Rivlin, L. G. (1987). The neighborhood, personal identity, and group affiliations. In I. Altman & A Wandersman (Eds.) Neighborhood and Community Environments, 1-34.

Rural School and Community Trust (2004). The fiscal impacts of school consolidation: Research based conclusions. Retrieved December 24, 2004 from The Rural School and Community Trust Web site: www.ruraledu.org

School boundaries: Top agenda. (1999, October 6). Salina Journal, pp A2.

Sell, Randall S., Leitstritz, F. Larry, Thompson, JoAnn M. (Year) Socio-economic impact of school consolidation on host and vacated communities. (Agricultural Econimics Report No. 347). Fargo, North Dakota, Agricultural Experiment Station.

Sher, Jonathan (1988). Class dismissed: Examining Nebraska’s rural education debate. Nebraska Rural Community Schools Association.

Sher, Jonathan (1992). Education in Rural america: A reassessment of conventional wisdom, Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Sher, J.P. and Tompkins, R. B. (1977). “Economy, Efficiency and Equity: The Myths of Rural School and District Consolidation.” In J.P. Sher (ed.) Education in Rural America (pp 43-77). Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Smith, D.T., & DeYoung, A.J. (1988) Big school small school: Conceptual, empirical, & political perspectives in the re-emerging debate. Journal of rural and small Schools, 1988, 2-11.

Spring, Joel (1987). Education and the song war. In J.W. Noll (Ed.) Taking sides: clashing views on controversial educational issues. (4th ed. pp. 123-128). Guilford, CN: The Dushkin Publishing Group.

Stockard J., & Mayberry, M. (1992). Resources and school and classroom size. In Educational Environments. (pp. 40-58) Newbury Park, CA: Corwin Press Inc.

Sybouts, Ward, & Bartling, Dan (1988). Rural school board presidents look at school reorganization. Unpublished manuscript. University of Nebraska, Bureau of Educational Research and Field Services, Lincoln.

Swysgood, Chuck (1994). Report presented at Annual Rural Education Conference, Western Montana College.

Tatge, S. (1992). Using geographical isolation factors in state education funding. Doctoral dissertation, Kansas State University, Manhattan.

Theobald, Paul, & Hachtigal, Paul (1995, October). Culture, community and the promise of rural education. Phi Delta Kappan, 132-135.

Tuan, Y.F. (1974). Topophilia: A study of environmental perception, attitudes, and values. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Tyack, David (1999, November 17). Democracy in education - who needs it? Education Week.

Tyack, David (1974). The one best system. Cambridge, MA: Howard University Press.

Valencia Richard R. (1984). School Closures and Policy Issues. Policy Paper No. 84-C3, ERIC No. ED323040.

Walberg, H.J. (1992). On local control: Is bigger better. In Source book on school district size, cost and quality. Hubert H. Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs, Oak Brook, IL. North Central Regional Laboratory. (ED 362 164 pp. 118-134)

Ward, J. G., & Rink, F.J. (1992). Analysis of local stakeholder opposition to school district consolidation: An application of interpretive theory to public policy making. Journal of Research in Rural Education, 8, (2), 11-19.

White, Wayne A. (1981). Rural school consolidation: Rationalization and social scarcity, Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Kansas State University, Manhattan.

Williams, D.T. (1990). The dimensions of education: Recent research on school size. Working Paper Series. ED 347006. Clemson University Strom Thurmond Institute of Government and Public Affairs, South Carolina


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Publication of the National Rural Education Association - http://www.nrea.net

Report problems or questions about to the website to jshedd@library.msstate.edu